Oxblood Booties For Fall

From left to right: Chinese Laundry "I Spy" for $110, DV by Dolce Vita "Coral" for $129, and Steve Madden "Cinch" for $129.

Okay so...I'm dying for a pair of deep oxblood booties to rock this fall.  The problem is, there are just too many options out there, hence sometimes I tend to want more than one pair of shoes in seemingly similar styles.  In this case, I've managed to narrow it down to three, and I think I might know which pair I'm leaning towards, but I'm not convinced. This is where you come in!! Help me decide. Which pair do you like best? Which would you buy for yourself? Considering that the quality and price point are similar across the board, this is purely a question of style.  Hoping to nail this down and make a purchase asap, even today if possible.  So please, please let me know what you think. Comments are appreciated and will absolutely factor into my decision :))